
The evidence is a cap badge showing a red pennant with LIBBY in white. Michael Faul identified it as the Libby Line, but Rosanoski strongly disputed that explanation, believing it confused Libby with Liverpool’s Bibby Line. Bibby’s flag is rectangular, not a pennant. Rosanoski considered Libby, McNeil & Libby a stronger possibility because it owned ships, while allowing that the badge might instead refer to a vessel named Libby. FOTW subsequently placed it under this company.
Libby McNeil & Libby remains candidate, not established proprietor.