Metal Complex Colour


Use d-electron count, geometry, ligand strength and charge transfer to explain the colour observations.
1. CrO3 is dark red. Explain why colour is observed.
2. trans-NiCl2(PCy3)2 (Cy = cyclohexyl, C6H11) is dark red and NiCl2(PPh3)2 is dark green. Explain why one complex is red and the other is green.
3. [Mn(H2O)6]Cl2 is pale red and Mn(CO)5Br is dark orange. Explain why one complex is pale and the other is dark.
4. Aqueous solutions of Mn7+ are intense purple colours, while aqueous solutions of Mn2+ (with more d electrons) are pale pink to almost colourless. Explain.
5. One type of "invisible ink" can be made by dissolving CoCl2 in H2O. The solution is pale pink (almost colourless) and therefore nearly invisible when it dries. When the receiver of the message exposes the paper to a source of heat (e.g., hair dryer) the message can be seen as dark blue writing. Explain the change in both shade and intensity of the colour.
6. [Ru(bipy)3]Cl2 is often used in photochemical studies. Although it is expected to be fainitly coloured (explain why), it is in fact a bright orange complex. Why is the actual colour intense?
7. When a coloured compound of a transition metal is heated, a colourless vapour is given off and the compound turns colourless. Explain what is happening.
8. Compounds of Ti3+ are usually purple, while Ti4+ compounds are colourless. Explain.
9. Tungsten hexachloride, WCl6, is unexpectedly dark purple. Explain.
10. CoCl2•6H2O is a red, crystalline compound. What colour would be expected for [Co(NH3)6]Cl3?. Explain.
11. Na2IrCl6•6H2O is dark red, almost appearing to be black. Explain why the colour of this octahedral complex is intense.
12. Fe(acac)3 is dark red, while Co(acac)3 is pale pink. Explain the difference in colour intensity.

 

Return to Topics List

 

Solutions


  
1.

CrO3 is d0, therefore the colour is not due to d→d transitions. Since Cr is in a high oxidation state (+6) and attached to electron-rich oxide ligands, the colour is caused by ligand-to-metal charge transfer (LMCT). The colour is dark because LMCT is not restricted by any selection rules.

   
   
  
2.
E   →
absorbed R O Y G B V
observed G B V R O Y

PCy3 is a stronger σ-donor and π-acceptor than PPh3, which results in the PCy3 complex to be square planar and the PPh3 complex to be tetrahedral. The d→d transtion is higher in energy for a square planar complex compared to a tetrahedral because the dx2-y2 orbital used in the square planar geometry lies along the bond axis, resulting in the anti-bonding b1g to be high in energy compared to the antibonding orbitals in a tetrahedral complex that result from poor orbital overlap (and are therefore lower) in energy. If red is observed (square planar), then green light is absorbed and if green is observed (tetrahedral) then red light is absorbed. Green light is higher energy than red light, corresponding to the energy differences between Δsp and Δt.

   
   
  
3. d5 high-spin octahedral
 

Cl and H2O are weak field ligands, which will result in the d5 Mn complex to be high-spin. All d orbitals will be occupied by 1 unpaired electron, therefore the transitions are forbidden because ΔS = 0 (there can be no spin flips). With six of the same ligands and all d orbitals equally occupied, the molecular geometry will be a perfect octahedral, so transiitons will only occur during vibrational distortions. Both of these factors will result in pale colour.



d6 low-spin octahedral
   
↿⇂ ↿⇂ ↿⇂
 

CO is a strong field ligand, which will result in the d6 Mn complex to be low-spin. The non-bonding t2g orbitals will each be occupied by 2 electrons, so electrons can jump to eg* without flipping their spins. Since there are 5 CO ligands and 1 Br ligand, the complex will be permanently distorted from Oh symmetry, and so there will be a permanent mixing of p and d orbitals. Both of these factors will result in an intense colour.

   
   
  
4.

Mn7+ is d0, therefore the colour is not due to d→d transitions. Since Mn is in a high oxidation state (+7) and attached to electron-rich water ligands, the colour is caused by ligand-to-metal charge transfer (LMCT). The colour is dark because LMCT is not restricted by any selection rules.



d5 high-spin octahedral
 

Mn2+ in H2O is d5 high-spin. All d orbitals will be occupied by 1 unpaired electron and the geometry will be a perfect octahedral, so transiitons will only occur during vibrational distortions, resulting in a pale colour.

   
   
  
5.
E   →
absorbed R O Y G B V
observed G B V R O Y

d7 high-spin octahedral
↿⇂ ↿⇂
 

CoCl2 in water results in an octahedral [Co(H2O)6]2+ complex, which is d7 high-spin. The d→d transitions are forbidden and so the colour is pale. Green light (complementary to red) is absorbed during vibrational distortions.


d7 tetrahedral
↿⇂ ↿⇂
 

Heating evaporates the water, leaving the d7 tetrahedral [CoCl4]2− complex. Tetrahedral complexes have permanent p and d orbital mixing, so e→t2 transitions are allowed (only d5 and d10 tetrahedral complexes should be pale due to the spin selection rule). Since Δt < Δo, the energy of the light absorbed is less. Orange light (complementary to blue) is absorbed, which is lower energy than green light.

   
   
  
6. d6 low-spin octahedral
   
↿⇂ ↿⇂ ↿⇂
 

bipy is a strong field ligand, which will result in the d6 Ru complex to be low-spin with perfect octahedral geometry, so the complex should be colourless. Since Ru is in a low oxidation state (+2) and attached to π-acceptor ligands, the colour is caused by metal-to-ligand charge transfer (MLCT). The colour is intense because MLCT is not restricted by any selection rules.

   
   
  
7.

The metal complex is most likely a hydrate (e.g., CuSO4•5H2O) and water is released during heating. The resultant dehydrated metal salt does not have water ligands splitting the d orbitals (into non-bonding and antibonding sets), so there are no electronic transitons within the visible spectrum.

   
   
  
8. d1 octahedral
   
   
 

Ti3+ is d1, with unequal occupation of the non-bonding t2g, resulting in a permanently distorted octahedral geometry. This gives the complex permanent p and d orbital mixing so transitions are allowed resulting in the observed colour.

Ti4+ is d0, therefore there are no d→d transitions possible and no colour.

   
   
  
9.

WCl6 is d0, therefore the colour is not due to d→d transitions. Since W is in a high oxidation state (+6) and attached to electron-rich chloride ligands, the colour is caused by ligand-to-metal charge transfer (LMCT). The colour is dark because LMCT is not restricted by any selection rules.

   
   
  
10.
E   →
absorbed R O Y G B V
observed G B V R O Y

Since NH3 is a stronger σ donor than H2O, Δo (and energy) will increase. When red is observed, green light is absorbed. So changing the ligand to NH3 will result in either blue or violet light being absorbed and an orange or yellow metal complex.

   
   
  
11. d5 high-spin octahedral
 

Ir4+ is d5 high-spin (since weak field ligands are present). This results in a perfect octahedral geometry, so d→d transitions are forbidden. Since Ir is in a high oxidation state (+4) and attached to electron-rich ligands, the colour is caused by ligand-to-metal charge transfer (LMCT). The colour is intense because LMCT is not restricted by any selection rules.

   
   
  
12. d5 low-spin octahedral
   
↿⇂ ↿⇂
 

Fe3+ is d5 and since the complex is dark red it must be low-spin (high-spin would be colourless). d5 low-spin has a distorted octahedral geometry with permanent p and d orbital mixing.



d6 low-spin octahedral
   
↿⇂ ↿⇂ ↿⇂
 

Co3+ is d6 and since the complex is pale pink it must be low-spin (high-spin would be coloured). d6 low-spin has a perfect octahedral geometry so d→d transitions are forbidden.

   
   
  

 

Return to Topics List